Does video game facilitated roleplaying actually exist?

I've had a precious few extended jags in World of Warcraft over the past few weeks as we prepare for our move, and as I played the game by myself I found that it was pretty easy to engage in the storyline. A few times, in fact, I actually felt invested that my character would want to actually help the world and it mattered.

Then I got the opportunity to run through an instance of Ragefire Chasm with some more experienced players. I understand that each person plays the game in their own way, and often the raids are about efficiency. My experience of actually engaging in the storyline was pretty well shattered by "talk to this guy, get this quest, then get back down there and more killing."

So I ask you, loyal readers... has anyone had a satisfactory roleplay experience using a packaged video game (such as WoW, Neverwinter, etc) as a medium? Granted, we weren't trying to replicate D&D style roleplay in our World of Warcraft efforts, but it was a bit amazing how quickly things devolved into hack and slash, efficiency gaming once a group came into the mix.

So let's hear it from you... does video game facilitated roleplay actually exist? Can it be done?

Visiting the Archives: Roleplaying Pitfalls pt. 2: Hogging The Spotlight

Today we bring you the second installment of Vanir's Roleplaying Pitfalls opus, where he details spotlight hogging and how to manage that urge!

---

Originally posted on 10/10/2007 by Vanir

I'm SO guilty of this one: you have concocted a brilliant idea that puts your character in the spotlight and provides hours of roleplaying opportunities - for you.

Enjoy your time in the spotlight, but don't hog it every week. If your group spends more time on hastily-constructed side quests that you caused (or worse, watching you complete them alone) than they do on the actual plot, you might want to back off a little bit.

If You Must Hog The Spotlight

Make sure it's worth it! In our group, we usually set aside some time every campaign for some PC-specific stuff, which is a lot of fun. So when it's not my character's turn and I decide to do something completely off the map, I usually try to do something to further the story in my own way.

A good example of this is the time I thought everybody in our party had been captured aside from Bat Loaf and I decided to convince a bunch of low level wizardry students to help me rescue my comrades by showing them how to score with the ladies. Off the tracks: you bet. Hogging the spotlight: check. Well-received by the party: well, nobody threw anything at me (even the Stupid Ranger!) and it was entertaining enough that everybody seemed to be having a good time!

An even better solution would be, if possible, to convince your compatriots to join you on your crazy mission. Your GM's head might explode, but at least you've involved everyone AND you still get to do what you wanted.

Metagame (Slightly)

There's a certain point where you just need to shut up and go with the party. Yeah, I know it's not what your character wants to do and he totally would just leave them and do his own thing in this case. Usually, a D&D campaign is based around the fact that the party has a common goal and is willing to work together to reach it. There's some leeway there, but by and large that's how this game works. As I frequently say on this blog, there are other people at the table, and they probably want to play too. Would you rather play D&D with your friends or continue to play in your sandbox by yourself?

Like so many other things, being in the spotlight is best when done in moderation. A little can be entertaining, too much isn't fun for anyone. Keep the lines of communication open with your group, and you'll find the right balance. Until next time!

Visiting the Archives: Roleplaying Pitfalls...

Last year, our good buddy Vanir created a truly excellent thread on Roleplaying Pitfalls. I would like to present the first installment wherein he examines schtick and its effect on your roleplaying experience.

---

Originally Posted on 10/7/2007 by Vanir-

In a lot of gaming groups I've played in, it's not an unusual occurrence for eyes to roll and mumbles of "damn it, not again" to be overheard when somebody decides to roleplay. Frequently, this is because the would-be roleplayer has decided to do something stupid and/or outrageous in the name of roleplaying. Having put much more emphasis on roleplaying in the last several years, I think I've figured out a major reason why -- and how to minimize its effects.

Schtick
When some people roleplay, it's more like they're following a list of unchangeable rules they've established for their character. They're dedicated to "fighting evil" and that's what they do no matter what.The worst example of this is the dreaded "attack on sight" mentality.

I've also seen a lot of people who think a particular concept would be funny and that's their character's schtick for the whole campaign. For instance, their character is afraid of rats so they'd make a big five minute deal about checking for rats under every snowbank if they were in the middle of the Arctic tundra. These kind of characters seem to me like the player is telling a joke that takes six months or more to tell -- but the punchline still makes everybody roll their eyes. It wouldn't be so bad if this was something this character does somewhat regularly in the course of roleplaying, but when it happens without fail, even during battle, it is murder-inspiringly annoying.

You've probably figured out by now that I'm not crazy about this particular brand of roleplaying. Either the characters just get irritating or the players do things that cause things to go horribly wrong "because that's what their character would do". Like charging a dozen orcs all by yourself with a first level wizard.

Of course, there are always the characters that you didn't mean to end up this way. These are the ones that you've honestly set out to roleplay fully, but either the concept didn't work out as well as you'd hoped or the setting changes or doesn't allow you to do what you had planned. And you end up doing the same thing over and over and over and getting bored. Bat Loaf is a very good example of this -- he was a ton of fun to play for the first 5-6 sessions. The problem with Bat was that there were many, many roleplaying opportunities well-suited for him in the beginning and it was fun because his misadventures would spill over into what the other players were doing and vice versa. As the story progressed these roleplaying encounters dried up in favor of Major Plot Events -- but there was still an inn, booze, and women in every town we'd travel to. Eventually the cycle of "go to inn, get drunk and find chick, run away, occasionally Inspire Courage +2 in combat" got old. For everyone, since it meant splitting the party pretty much every single session. And it just got boring for me.

Intentional or not, the problem with schtick is that it eventually gets in the way. One-trick PC's are either a direct hindrance to the game for everyone, or they just aren't fun anymore after awhile.


The Cure

I think schtick comes from three sources: lack of imagination, laziness, and an inability to sense danger. A little effort goes a long way when making your character. And the reason the other players get irritated when a Schticky player does things is because he's not playing the same game they are anymore. He's playing his own and doesn't care about the consequences for everyone else. Which makes them want to hurt him.

Here's a few ways to avoid personal bodily injury:

• Well-Developed Characters
  Well-developed backstory and character motivations and schtick don't mix. They cannot exist together. A well-developed character with a frequent quirk is fine - it's just a personality trait and doesn't define the character. The difference? A one-trick PC is that same quirk armed with a battleaxe.


• Acknowledge That Your Character Has Intelligence
  Your character REALLY hates orcs. Your character is also, in most cases, an experienced warrior. They know it's dumb to face a dozen orcs alone. Instead of attacking them all, think of strategies. You might even use (gasp) TEAMWORK. Or decide that you could do more damage later if you live to fight another day. Most one-trick PC's are roleplayed as if their INT was about 6 or 7. Their INT scores are probably much higher, which means they wouldn't think in such simplistic terms as "ORC! BOB SMASH NOW!". Act smarter than that, and make your PC's act smarter than that.


• Change Things Up
  Nothing says your PC can't change if it's not working as planned. Hell, an emotional crossroads makes for a good roleplaying excuse. Incidentally, that's how I saved Bat Loaf from one-trick PC hell -- I married him off, got him some new abilities, and had him start a bardic rock academy / militia. All of a sudden the old boring stuff became backstory for me to build on and he's fun again.

Hopefully, this will significantly decrease the number of eye-rolls at your gaming table. Have you had problems with Schtick in your gaming group? We'd love to hear them, and how you deal with it.

In the next installment of Roleplaying Pitfalls, I'll talk about another issue plaguing today's modern roleplayer: the dreaded Spotlight Hog!

Until next time....

<evil laughter>

Oh wait, wrong column. My bad!